[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Site Map
Quest. & Ans.
For Teachers
Review (1)
Review (2)
Central link

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

#28a.     The Direction Assigned to Electric Currents

  (Files in red–history)


26. Polar Caps

26H. Birkeland, 1895

27. Aurora from Space

28. Aurora Origin

28a. Plus and Minus

29. Low Polar Orbit

30. Magnetic Storms

30a. Chicago Aurora

31. Space Weather

32. Magnetic planets

33. Cosmic Rays

          The choice of which type of electricity is called "positive" and which "negative" was made around 1750 by Ben Franklin, early American scientist and man of many talents (the stamp on the left commemorates his role as first US postmaster--and colonial postmaster before that). Franklin studied static electricity, produced by rubbing glass, amber, sulfur etc. with fur or dry cloth. Among his many discoveries was proof that lightning was a discharge of electricity, by the foolhardy experiment (he claimed) of flying a kite in a thunderstorm. The kite string produced large sparks but luckily no lightning, which could have killed Franklin.

        Franklin knew of two types of electric charge, depending on the material one rubbed. He thought that one kind signified a little excess of the "electric fluid" over the usual amount, and he called that "positive" electricity (marked by +), while the other kind was "negative" (marked -), signifying a slight deficiency. It is not known whether he tossed a coin before deciding to call the kind produced by rubbing glass "positive" and the other "resinous" type "negative" (rather than the other way around), but he might just as well have.

    Later, when electric batteries were discovered, scientists naturally assigned the direction of the flow of current to be from (+) to (-). A century after that electrons were discovered and it was suddenly realized that in metal wires the electrons were the ones that carried the current, moving in exactly the opposite direction. Also, it was an excess of electrons which produced a negative electric charge. However, it was much too late to change Franklin's naming convention

    A Simple Experiment

    Ben Franklin's kite experiment observed atmospheric electricity, of which lightning is just the most extreme form. The electric charge originates in thunderheads (cumulo-nimbus clouds) by a process is described in the last part of a file on the Van de Graaff generator of static electricity. In thunderstorms and below them the electrification is strong and lightning occurs, but it spreads over large areas, though at distant points it gets weak.

    A simple experiment for observing this electricity was described on a web-list by Larry Cartwright, retired physics teacher in Michigan:

        "If you like experimenting with everyday stuff (what the heck would you be doing teaching physics if you didn't like experimenting, right?), find a building with ungrounded aluminum siding and connect a small neon lamp between the siding and a grounded pipe or rod. The lamp flashes whenever the siding reaches a certain potential w/respect to ground. (Faster flashing = higher electrification)

        You might get some surprises about the kinds of weather that produce substantial charges on the building's surface. A few years back, a person was killed at a park near here by a freak lightning strike on a practically clear and sunny summer day.

        You can get the little NE-2 lamps at electronics parts suppliers such as Radio Shack, at a hardware store (getting harder and harder to find traditional hardware stores), and in the tools/hardware department of any well-equipped discount Mart or home building supplies center. Multi-megohm resistors can be used to decrease the sensitivity of the lamp if you wish.

        By the way, definitely do not put yourself between the siding and the ground on a cumulonimbus kind of day!"

Futher reading:

A large site on Franklin "The Electric Benjamin Franklin."

Last updated 25 June 2003
Re-formatted 9-28-2004